Lisbon Friday, 20 November 2026Fri 20 Nov

Updated Search

Lisbon, Portugal and the world. News in English.

Lisbon News

Socialists Reject Claim Their Budget Changes Cause 0.2% Deficit

The PS says its roughly 180 changes to the 2027 state budget will not push Portugal into deficit, as the finance minister claims. Here is each side's case.

Stunning photo of Canada's Parliament Hill in Ottawa under a clear sky.
Photo: Splash of Rain / Pexels

Portugal’s Socialist Party (PS) said on Monday that its proposed changes to the 2027 state budget (Orçamento do Estado, OE2027) cannot push the country into a deficit. The party was answering Finance Minister Joaquim Miranda Sarmento, who says the proposals would turn an estimated 2027 surplus of 0.1% of gross domestic product into a deficit of 0.2%.

António Mendonça Mendes, vice-president of the PS parliamentary group, made the case to reporters in parliament, as reported by CNN Portugal, Público and Observador. The proposals include a temporary cut in fuel tax, a doubling of support for farm diesel and a VAT exemption on essential foods.

What the PS is proposing

The Socialists have tabled about 180 amendments to the budget. Among them is a temporary reduction of the ISP (Imposto sobre os Produtos Petrolíferos e Energéticos, the fuel tax) equal to cutting VAT on fuel from 23% to 13%. It would take effect on Jan. 1, 2027, and last three months at first.

The party also wants to double support for agricultural diesel, from the current 10 cents per litre to 20 cents, and to exempt a basket of essential foods from VAT.

To pay for the fuel measure, the PS proposes suspending during 2027 the planned one percentage point cut in IRC (corporate income tax). The food VAT exemption would be financed by revoking tax incentives tied to so-called moderate rents, which have a ceiling of €2,300. According to the party, all its proposals would cost about €480 million and bring in more than €500 million in associated revenue.

The finance minister’s objections

Miranda Sarmento said the PS measures would leave the budget in deficit rather than surplus. On Friday in parliament, he argued that suspending the IRC cut would affect tax revenue only in 2028, so it could not fund a fuel tax cut in 2027. He also criticized the PS for proposing measures lasting only three months, and others have raised doubts about whether zero VAT actually lowers food prices.

The Socialist reply

Mendonça Mendes called the minister’s claim a dramatization and said there is no chance the measures, if approved, would lead to a deficit. He said the only reason the minister would exaggerate is that he knows something about the budget the opposition does not, which would suggest Miranda Sarmento does not believe his own fiscal targets.

On the timing of the IRC effect, he said the minister’s statement was not accurate. In his account, the companies that pay most of the corporate tax adjust what they owe for the current year at their third payment on account, and do not wait until the following year when they file their annual return (the Modelo 22 form).

On the three-month limit, he said the minister had not read every proposal. One of them calls for a monthly assessment of extra tax revenue generated when inflation runs above what the budget assumed. The aim is to return that money to taxpayers from April 1, 2027, through measures judged more suitable at the time.

On zero VAT, he said the 2023 experience showed consumers did feel the lower tax and that the government must enforce it effectively. He added that tax cuts and the offsetting measures cannot be voted on separately.

What’s at stake

The disagreement comes down to different priorities, according to the PS. Mendonça Mendes said the government prefers a tax benefit for landlords with rents of €2,300 over lowering VAT on food, and a lower IRC rate over cheaper fuel for families and businesses. The party maintains that the budget balance would remain positive as far as it is concerned.

The two sides disagree on the size and timing of the revenue effects, with a 0.2% deficit on one side and a positive balance on the other.

Sources: CNN Portugal, Público, Observador

Site editor: Nikita Sheikin

Also in Lisbon News