IPMA Says Charles Gusts Peaked at 123 km/h After Alert Row
IPMA explains why it issued red warnings for storm Charles, whose top gust was 123 km/h, as critics question the nationwide state of alert.

Portugal’s weather institute IPMA (Instituto Português do Mar e da Atmosfera) published a statement on Thursday explaining how it handled depression Charles, which turned out weaker than forecast after the government had put the whole country under a state of alert for Wednesday. The strongest gust recorded in the country was 123 km/h at Fóia, in Monchique, according to Observador.
The statement came after criticism that a nationwide alert, with schools and universities closed, went further than the storm required.
How the IPMA forecast changed from Sunday to Wednesday
IPMA says the first signs appeared on Sunday, when models showed a depression southeast of Bermuda heading toward Madeira with “high uncertainty” and possible paths between Morocco and northern mainland Portugal. On Monday, Nov. 9, a path toward the mainland became more likely, and several models showed an extreme deepening of the low. About 36 hours before arrival, the institute issued its first orange wind warning, for areas south of the Leiria district, and waited for new model runs before going higher.
On Tuesday, Nov. 10, the track was better defined but still ranged between Cabo de Sines and Cabo Carvoeiro. The European Centre for Medium-Range Weather Forecasts model pointed to gusts up to 160 km/h in the Greater Lisbon area. The AROME model, which IPMA runs four times a day, showed 130 to 160 km/h in the same area. With 24 hours to go, IPMA issued a red wind warning for every district south of Leiria.
The interior minister, Luís Neves, announced the state of alert for the whole country that morning, asked people to telework where possible, and said schools, universities and non-essential public services would close.
Why the forecast eased
Later on Tuesday, satellite images showed the system moving farther south than the models had predicted as it approached Madeira. Models run at 12h then showed a significant change in track and strength. By the 18h runs, the southern path lowered the probability of the worst scenarios without ruling them out, IPMA said, and it passed this to the civil protection authority ANEPC (Autoridade Nacional de Emergência e Proteção Civil) and chose to wait for more data before changing warnings.
Overnight into Wednesday the storm split into two cores, one entering the Lisbon area and the other the Algarve. IPMA then began lowering wind warnings in several districts. Rain was treated differently: the weaker low did not reduce expected rainfall, and the institute kept red rain warnings in some districts.
What was measured
IPMA says the gusts were below forecast and matched a yellow warning (70 to 90 km/h on the southern coast), with exposed points reaching levels compatible with orange. For rain, it says the red warning was justified by accumulation over six hours. Several stations in the Lisbon district recorded 60 to 80 mm. All districts in the south, plus Santarém and Castelo Branco, reached values compatible with an orange warning (40 to 60 mm in six hours).
What critics and the government said
Gustavo Paulo Duarte, president of the Confederação do Comércio e Serviços de Portugal (the national trade and services confederation), said prevention is mandatory but must not mean stopping the country. He referred to the cost of depression Kristin in January. Artur Costa, head of civil protection at Universidade Lusófona do Porto, told Público that identical measures for the whole country were hard to justify, given forecasts of greater intensity in the Centre and South, and that a distinction from Aveiro northward would have made sense. PS leader Luís Carneiro said regional measures based on risk level should be considered, as was done in past wildfires.
Prime Minister Luís Montenegro said the storm did not have the impact predicted, though some places faced heavy pressure, and defended acting early. Civil protection secretary of state Rui Rocha called the criticism “unfair” and said the government could not adjust decisions hour by hour. He said the forecast still pointed to heavy rain across the whole country, northern region included.
Why it matters for residents
The episode shows how IPMA colors translate into government action. A red warning in the south led to closures and telework requests across the country. Readers can see the meaning of each level in our guide to IPMA weather warnings in Lisbon. The dispute over whether alerts should vary by region is still open, since the opposition and some specialists want it and the government has not changed its position.
Source: Observador
Site editor: Nikita Sheikin



