Lisbon Friday, 20 November 2026Fri 20 Nov

Updated Search

Lisbon, Portugal and the world. News in English.

Portugal

Court Rejects Montenegro’s Bid to Keep Spinumviva Accounts Private

Portugal's Constitutional Court dismissed the prime minister's argument against publishing Spinumviva's bank balances. Here is what each side said.

An elegant view of classic architectural columns with an antique street lamp.
Photo: Brett Sayles / Pexels

Portugal’s Constitutional Court (Tribunal Constitucional) has published its reasoning for rejecting an appeal by Prime Minister Luis Montenegro, who tried to stop the public from seeing the bank balances of his family company, Spinumviva. The ruling, numbered 950/2026, is dated Nov. 3 and was released on Monday, according to CNN Portugal and ECO.

It is one of two appeals the prime minister filed against decisions of the Entity for Transparency (Entidade para a Transparencia) on public access to information about the company. The court looked at the substance of the objection and found no sufficient grounds to restrict access to the balances.

What Montenegro argued

According to the ruling, Montenegro told the court that a company’s bank balance is a changing figure tied to its normal financial cycle. He said it can reflect one-off client payments, advances, and money set aside for suppliers, salaries, taxes, subcontractors or other debts that are due or about to fall due.

He argued that publishing the balances without the company’s accounts, liabilities and payment calendar could lead to wrong conclusions about liquidity, solvency and profitability. A company balance, he said, is not the same as a personal balance, because it reflects a temporary financial position of a separate legal entity.

He also said publication would create “skewed media perceptions” and “undue and unnecessary social suspicion,” and could harm commercial negotiations, credit relations and the trust of suppliers, clients and workers. The balances, he added, involve ongoing obligations to third parties such as partners, creditors and subcontractors.

What the court answered

The judges said his argument was not particular to his own case and would apply to every holder of political office in the same position. They dismissed the request because it was general in nature rather than tied to specific circumstances.

Citing earlier case law, the court noted that the clash between the right to privacy and the demands of transparency has already been weighed by lawmakers, and that the disclosure regime has been found constitutional. A public office holder, the court said, cannot rely only on reasons that apply to all people who must make such declarations.

The court also found the duty to declare this kind of data proportionate. It stressed that the obligation covers only term deposits and financial investments above 50 minimum salaries.

Why it matters

On Nov. 6, the prime minister’s office told the news agency Lusa that the court had not decided the underlying question and had relied on formal and procedural arguments. Its reasoning had not been published at that point. The published ruling says the court did examine the merits of the objection to access.

The decision sets out in writing how the court treats a politician’s claim that disclosure of company finances would mislead the public.

Sources: CNN Portugal, ECO

Site editor: Nikita Sheikin

Also in Portugal